Measure visits to this site with Google Analytics? Only with your OK. Privacy
Acteurly

Google Ads or Facebook Ads: a 2-minute test for small budgets

By the Acteurly team · · 8 min read

In short

Google Ads captures demand that already exists: someone is typing what you sell. Facebook and Instagram (Meta) create demand among people who weren't looking. On a small budget, don't split it: take the searched-or-shown test (6 questions), start with Google at 3 or more and Meta at 2 or less, and give Meta whatever Google can't spend.

Monday, 9 p.m.: two tabs open, $600 to spend

Monday, 9 p.m. Google Ads in one tab, Meta in the other, $600 a month to spend and three pieces of advice fighting in your head: "Facebook is cheaper," "Google is where people buy," "do both, half and half."

All three start from the wrong question. The right one: tonight, is someone in your area already typing what you sell into Google? If so, the demand exists and Google captures it. If not, demand has to be created, and that's what Facebook and Instagram do. Our position: on a small budget, you choose based on the moment a customer meets you, and you don't split the money down the middle.

Google says as much itself: Search campaigns reach people while they're searching. On Facebook and Instagram, your ad reaches people who weren't looking for you, but who are definitely there: according to Université Laval's NETendances survey, Quebec internet users who use social media spend 3 hours 41 minutes a day on it (in French).

The line doesn't follow the brand names: Google creates demand too, with Demand Gen campaigns that serve ads on YouTube, Discover, Gmail and the Display Network. The real choice is between two moments.

What changesSearched (Google Search)Shown (Facebook and Instagram)
Who sees the adSomeone who already has the needSomeone who wasn't thinking about you
Your jobBe there with the right answerCreate the desire, visually, in seconds
Where it stallsNobody searches for what you sellYour local audience is too small

Two minutes to decide

The searched-or-shown test: Google, Meta, or neither for now?

First, three locks. A single "no" means neither Google nor Meta for now.

  • Can someone answer every enquiry the same day?
  • Does your landing page exist in French, with an obvious way to reach you?
  • Do you know what a new customer is worth to you (the margin on their first purchase)?

Then six questions. Score 1 point for each "yes."

  1. When the need comes up, do your customers type it into Google in plain words ("physio Drummondville," "emergency plumber")?
  2. Is the need urgent: does the customer want it dealt with this week?
  3. In Google Ads' Keyword Planner (you'll need to enter billing information first), do your top five keywords show monthly searches in your area?
  4. Did your customers know your type of product or service existed before they found you?
  5. Do they usually compare two or three suppliers before buying?
  6. Is your offer hard to make appealing in a photo or a ten-second video?

Your score:

  • 0 to 2: shown. Start with Meta. Keep at most a small Google campaign on the rare exact searches: it won't spend much.
  • 3 to 4: both moments exist. Start with Google and apply the overflow rule.
  • 5 to 6: searched. Google only for three months.

The overflow rule: set a daily budget on a Google Search campaign with tight keywords (phrase and exact match). After two weeks, look at what Google actually spent. Whatever it can't spend, for lack of searches, becomes your Meta budget. Existing demand gets served first; the money left over goes to creating more.

A worked example: a clinic and a studio, same budget

Take two fictional businesses, each with $600 a month. All figures are assumptions for the example, not market averages.

A physiotherapy clinic in Drummondville scores 5 out of 6 ("no" to question 5: patients often book with the first clinic that has an opening).

  • On Google: at $3.50 a click, $600 buys about 171 clicks (600 ÷ 3.50 ≈ 171.4). If 6% of clicks become an enquiry, that's 10 enquiries (171 × 0.06 ≈ 10.3). Six become patients: $600 ÷ 6 = $100 per new patient.
  • On Meta: at $0.90 a click, the same $600 buys about 667 clicks (600 ÷ 0.90 ≈ 666.7). These people weren't looking: 1.2% make an enquiry, so 8 enquiries (667 × 0.012 ≈ 8.0), and 3 become patients. $600 ÷ 3 = $200 per new patient.

The Facebook click is almost four times cheaper (3.50 ÷ 0.90 ≈ 3.9), but the patient costs twice as much. Always compare cost per customer, worked out from your own sales, never cost per click.

A ceramics studio in Saint-Hyacinthe sells eight-week classes at $320, with a 60% margin, so $192 per sign-up (320 × 0.60). It scores 1 out of 6: only question 4 is a "yes." As its score suggests, it keeps a small Google campaign on exact searches and gives the rest to Meta, using the overflow rule.

  • On Google: $20 a day on tight keywords, but hardly anyone searches for "pottery classes Saint-Hyacinthe." The campaign spends only $120 in the month: 40 clicks at $3, 3 enquiries, 1 sign-up. That's $120 per sign-up.
  • On Meta: the remaining $480 (600 − 120). At $1.20 a click, that's 400 clicks (480 ÷ 1.20). At 1.5%, 6 enquiries (400 × 0.015), and half of them sign up: 3 sign-ups, or $160 each (480 ÷ 3).

Google finds the cheapest sign-up, but only one: not enough to fill a class of eight. Meta costs more and still passes the margin test ($160 under $192). Altogether, 4 sign-ups for $600, or $150 each. Putting everything on Google would have led to "ads don't work."

What most advice gets wrong

  1. Splitting the budget in two. With $300 on each side at $3.50 a click, Google gives you about 85 clicks (300 ÷ 3.50 ≈ 85.7): two half-tests that prove nothing. Concentrate, then expand.
  2. Counting on retargeting in month one. Meta's lookalike audiences need a source of at least 100 people from one country. A site with 200 visits a month doesn't feed much.
  3. Forgetting special ad categories. On Meta, employment, housing and credit ads targeting Canada fall under special ad categories: no gender targeting, age generally fixed at 18 to 65+, no lookalike audiences, and a minimum radius around every location. On Google, in Canada, you can't target by gender, age, parental status, marital status or postal code in those three sectors.

The Quebec reality: language, regions, seasons

French, including in the image. According to the OQLF's social media guide (in French), commercial posts aimed at the Quebec market must be in French, including the text in images and videos. A version in another language is allowed if the French version is at least equivalent. Build the French ad first, then a separate English version. The guide isn't a legal opinion: if in doubt, ask a lawyer.

Small markets work against both platforms. In a town of 15,000 people, many keywords will get Google's "low search volume" status and sit inactive. On Meta, a small audience keeps seeing the same ad: widen the radius to your real service area and change the visual often.

The seasons set the order. A tire change gets searched in October; a sugar shack or a patio gets shown, a few weeks before the season. Show before, capture during.

The pixel and Law 25. Retargeting on Meta relies on a pixel installed on your site. Quebec's privacy regulator, the Commission d'accès à l'information, notes that technologies able to identify, locate or profile a person can't be turned on by default under Quebec's Law 25 (in French). Before you install the pixel, talk to whoever manages your site and, if needed, a lawyer.

AI changes the scenery, not the question

On Google, search is becoming a conversation. In Canada, ads in AI Overviews run in English only, you can't opt out, and Google requires targeting such as broad match. In late October 2026, Google also announced it is scaling ads in AI Mode in Canada. The searched moment remains, in the form of a full question. This week, write down the ten questions customers ask you on the phone: they're your best keywords and the content your page needs.

On Meta, the machine makes the variations. Advantage+ creative can now generate video from your static images, and Meta is giving its AI assistant the ability to change an ad's budget through conversation. Your job: supply real photos (team, shop, before-and-after) and review every generated version, in French.

The honest limit. The test gives you a direction, not a return. Neither platform will fix an overpriced offer or missed calls. In B2B, with 30 target companies in your region, a phone and a trade show will do better. And if you work in a regulated profession, check your professional order's advertising rules first.

Your plan for the next 14 days

  1. Day 1: take the test. Write down your score and the margin on a first purchase.
  2. Day 2: a lock came up "no"? Fix it first.
  3. Days 3 and 4: if you scored 3 or more, set up a Google Search campaign on tight keywords, in French. If you scored 2 or less, prepare three Meta ads in French using your own photos.
  4. Days 5 to 13: leave it alone. Log every enquiry and where it came from.
  5. Day 14: work out your cost per enquiry. If you're on Google, look at what it couldn't spend: that's the budget for your first Meta test.

A month from now, you'll know where your customers meet you. That's the only answer that matters.

Frequently asked questions

What's the minimum budget to start advertising on Facebook or Instagram?

Meta has a minimum daily budget, and Ads Manager warns you when yours is too low. The real floor is somewhere else: you need enough money to get a few enquiries in a month. Divide your budget by the cost per enquiry you're aiming for; if the answer is under 5, run the test longer rather than judging too soon.

Google Ads or Facebook Ads for a restaurant?

A restaurant lives in both moments. "Restaurants near me" is searched, often in Google Maps, while the urge to try a new brunch spot is created by a picture. Start with an up-to-date Google Business Profile, which is free and captures searches, then pay Meta to show your dishes to people who live or work close enough to come in.

Can a Quebec business advertise in English only?

According to Quebec's French-language office (OQLF), commercial posts aimed at the Quebec market must be in French. An English version is allowed alongside it, as long as the French version is at least equivalent. To reach English-speaking customers, plan two versions rather than an English-only ad, and check with a lawyer if you're unsure.

Should I choose between Facebook and Instagram?

Not at the start. Both are bought in Meta's Ads Manager, and one campaign can run your ads on both. Let it run for a few weeks, then look at where your enquiries come from rather than your clicks: that's where the budget should go.

In Acteurly

Read next