Website visits but no calls? Find your real rate first
By the Acteurly team · · 7 min read
Before rebuilding a website that gets visits but no calls, remove the four intruders from your traffic (the curious, job seekers, current customers, out-of-area visitors) and calculate your real rate on the prospects left. Then score your page out of 14 with the sidewalk test: under 7, start with a tappable number at the top and a form of 5 fields or fewer.
Thursday, 10:05 p.m.: 1,200 visits, 9 leads
Thursday, 10:05 p.m. Google Analytics shows 1,200 visits this month. In your lead log, new leads that came through the website, by phone or form: nine. Under 1%. The obvious conclusion: the site needs a rebuild.
Not so fast. Our position: before you fix your website, fix your math. "Visits" lumps together people who will never call you, however good the site is: job seekers, customers looking to pay an invoice, curious readers from the other side of the world. As long as they stay in the calculation, you can't tell whether your site has a problem, let alone which one.
The method has two steps. The four-intruder sort removes everyone who isn't a prospect and gives you your real rate. The sidewalk test then looks at the site on a phone, the way a customer in a hurry sees it. The first tells you how much you're losing; the second tells you where.
The four-intruder sort: who is really visiting your site
Take one full month. In Google Analytics 4, the Landing page report (Reports, then Engagement) shows the first page each visitor lands on and how many land there. Then remove, in this order, each visit only once:
- The curious. They land on an informational post ("why does my breaker keep tripping"), read it and leave. That isn't a failure: they were never prospects.
- Job seekers. Every visit that starts on your Careers page. When you're hiring, they add up fast.
- Current customers. They search your name to find your hours or the payment page. In Search Console, the Branded / Non-branded query filter separates searches that include your name from the rest; count their clicks. It isn't available for sites with few impressions, so scan the query list by hand instead.
- Out-of-area visitors. If you serve the Laurentians, north of Montréal, a visit from Lyon won't turn into a call. But the city Google Analytics shows is approximated from the IP address: a customer in Mirabel can show up as Montréal. Remove only the obvious, another country or another province.
Bots? Google Analytics automatically excludes known bots. The others, often spikes of one-second visits from far away, go out with the out-of-area visits.
Worked example: an electrician in Saint-Jérôme
Take a six-person residential electrician in Saint-Jérôme. All figures are assumptions for the example.
The real contact rate calculation, to copy
- Visits this month: 1,200
- Minus the curious (breaker post, read mostly in France): 330, leaving 870
- Minus job seekers: 150, leaving 720
- Minus current customers: 240, leaving 480
- Minus out-of-area: 120, leaving 360
- Prospect visits: 360
- New leads from the website, per the log: 9
- Displayed rate: 9 ÷ 1,200 = 0.75%
- Real rate: 9 ÷ 360 = 2.5%, one lead per 40 prospects
Your numbers:
- Visits this month: ___
- Curious: ___ · Job seekers: ___ · Current customers: ___ · Out-of-area: ___
- Prospect visits: ___
- New leads from the website: ___
- Real rate: ___ ÷ ___ × 100 = ___ (as a percentage)
Two lessons. Only 30% of visits (360 of 1,200) are prospects, so doubling the blog would inflate visits without adding calls. Now suppose that after the sidewalk test the rate rises from 2.5% to 3.5%. On the same 360 visits, 360 × 3.5% = 12.6 leads, or 3 to 4 more a month. To get those 3.6 extra leads at today's rate, you would need 3.6 ÷ 2.5% = 144 more prospect visits, which means 144 ÷ 30% = 480 more visits in total. Fixing a page often costs less than buying that traffic.
The sidewalk test: does your site make people want to call?
Go outside. Standing on the sidewalk, on your phone, off the office Wi-Fi, open the page prospects visit most (usually a service page, not the home page). Score each question 0, 1 or 2.
The 7-question sidewalk test: does your website make the phone ring?
- Is the number visible without scrolling, and does tapping it start a call? 2 = yes to both; 1 = only one of the two (a number in an image, for example); 0 = neither.
- Within five seconds, can people tell what you do and where? 2 = service and service area written at the top; 1 = only one; 0 = neither.
- Is the form short, and does it work? Nielsen Norman Group recommends 3 to 5 fields, asking only what you need to respond. 2 = 5 fields or fewer, and your test submission arrived; 1 = 6 to 8 fields; 0 = more than 8, or your test never arrived.
- Does the page load fast? In Google's free PageSpeed Insights tool, check mobile LCP: 2.5 seconds or less is good, more than 4 seconds is poor. 2 = 2.5 s or less; 1 = 2.5 to 4 s; 0 = more than 4 s.
- Are your hours and response time posted? The same study found most people expect a reply to a form within 24 hours. 2 = both; 1 = one; 0 = neither.
- Can the customer see a price range? 2 = a range or a "starting at"; 1 = what drives the price, without a number; 0 = nothing.
- Does the language switch lead to the same page? 2 = the Français button opens this same service page, with the same number and the same form; 1 = it sends people back to the home page; 0 = no second language, even though you serve customers in both. If you serve only one language, score 2.
Your score out of 14. 0 to 6: the site is holding calls back; fix questions 1 and 3 this week. 7 to 10: it works, but leaves calls on the table; fix one 0 or 1 a week. 11 to 14: the site probably isn't the problem; look at traffic quality, your Google Business Profile or what happens after the call.
What most advice gets wrong
It wants more traffic. If 70% of your visits aren't prospects, more blog posts mostly add more curious readers. Aim at the "prospect visits" line, not the total.
It compares your rate to an industry average. A rate calculated on all visits mostly reflects your share of job seekers and current customers. It doesn't compare to anything.
It measures clicks, not calls. Google Analytics enhanced measurement counts form submissions and outbound clicks, described as links that lead to another website. Don't assume a tap on your phone number gets counted: have an event created for those taps, then mark it as a key event (Admin, Data display, Events, then the star). And anyone who reads your number on a computer and dials it on their phone is invisible to every tool: your lead log and the question "how did you find us?" remain the reference.
It replaces the phone with a form. In the Nielsen Norman Group study, people saw forms as barriers. Keep the number.
Quebec, AI and the honest limits
Two languages, two paths. A Quebec business must offer its website in French; an English version is allowed as long as a French version of comparable quality is available, as Éducaloi explains. A form that exists in only one language is a customer walking away. For your exact obligations, check with the Office québécois de la langue française (OQLF) or a lawyer.
AI assistants read your site. In the U.S., Google Search can already call local businesses to get pricing and availability on the user's behalf. The announcement covers only the U.S., but it shows the direction: more and more, a machine will read your answers before the customer does. This week, put your service area, hours and a price range on the site as text, not inside an image.
What this sort can't fix. Below about a hundred prospect visits a month, one lead more or less moves the rate by a full point or more, so judge by the quarter. The site can't make up for an off-market price or a phone that rings into the void; for that, see how to reply to quote requests within 24 hours. In B2B, where a contract takes months, count booked meetings.
Your plan for the next 7 days
- Monday, 20 minutes: open the Landing page report for the last full month and do the four-intruder sort.
- Tuesday: count the new leads that came through the website that month and work out your real rate.
- Wednesday, on the sidewalk: run the test on your most-visited service page. Send yourself the form and call yourself by tapping the number.
- Thursday and Friday: fix the lowest score among questions 1 to 3.
- In a month: redo the sort the same way and compare the real rate, not the visits.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good conversion rate for a small business website?
There is no reliable universal number, because the rate depends mostly on who visits your site. A site that draws lots of job seekers or blog readers will show a low rate even when it works well. The useful benchmark is your own real rate, calculated on prospect visits and compared month to month using the same method.
How can I tell whether a call came from my website or my Google Business Profile?
The simplest way is still to ask every new customer how they found you and write it in your lead log. You can also have taps on the website's number counted as an event in Google Analytics, which gives you a trend rather than an exact total. Some businesses show a separate number on the website; if you do, keep the same main number everywhere else, including your Google Business Profile.
Should I put prices on my website?
Not necessarily an exact price, especially if every job is different. But a range, a "starting at" figure or a list of what drives the price helps customers place themselves before they call. You may get slightly fewer calls from people outside your budget, and more from people ready to go ahead.
Form or phone: which should come first on a mobile site?
Both, but the number first on mobile, at the top of the page and tappable. Many customers in a hurry would rather talk to someone, and a form on its own leaves them waiting without knowing when you'll reply. The form serves people who write in the evening: keep it short and post your response time right beside it.
How long should I wait before judging whether my fixes worked?
At least one full month, comparing the real rate calculated the same way, not the number of visits. If you get fewer than about a hundred prospect visits a month, wait a quarter instead, since a few leads more or less are enough to move the rate. Avoid changing several things at once if you want to know what worked.